|
Post by Clubber Lang on Sept 16, 2014 11:47:26 GMT -4
I think for Halifax to make that deal they'd have to have a commitment from the kid beforehand, or at least you'd think. That being said, something like Murphy for O'Leary and a 1st would be really nice at christmas, especially if O'Leary reported right away. Lets the kids play more minutes on the blue-line and possibly pushes Bent off the team haha. Um who is Bent?
|
|
|
Post by Citris on Sept 16, 2014 11:52:58 GMT -4
I should clarify I'm a Halifax fan, and am talking from a Mooseheads perspective on that trade. Kelly Bent, the 19 year old former Rocket/Olympique/Sea Dog.
|
|
|
Post by Clubber Lang on Sept 16, 2014 12:35:13 GMT -4
I should clarify I'm a Halifax fan, and am talking from a Mooseheads perspective on that trade. Kelly Bent, the 19 year old former Rocket/Olympique/Sea Dog. No problem. Thanks i thought for a moment i was losing it.
|
|
|
Post by statsman18 on Sept 16, 2014 13:00:18 GMT -4
If you guys are worried about not having good 20's for next year I will like to add that 20's will not cost as much as a 19 this year. The cost of a decent twenty is usually one early to mid round draft pick. However , the risk is greater though because that may be too late to get a star 20. If going in a bit this year then it will make sense to get some 19's now though. At this point I am good with going for either option. If Darcy comes back then maybe keep Legare and swing a deal with Hfx for Fucale and Murphy? For this trade to happen they would have to kiss good bye Dubois, O'Leary a 1st rounder and maybe even Bell.
|
|
|
Post by statsman18 on Sept 16, 2014 13:03:24 GMT -4
I think for Halifax to make that deal they'd have to have a commitment from the kid beforehand, or at least you'd think. That being said, something like Murphy for O'Leary and a 1st would be really nice at christmas, especially if O'Leary reported right away. Lets the kids play more minutes on the blue-line and possibly pushes Bent off the team haha. If that trade was made the commitment would already be done. They wouldn't do it unless they had O'Learys word. Other wise CB would have to give up Dubois and a 1st.
|
|
|
Post by Citris on Sept 16, 2014 14:20:39 GMT -4
If you guys are worried about not having good 20's for next year I will like to add that 20's will not cost as much as a 19 this year. The cost of a decent twenty is usually one early to mid round draft pick. However , the risk is greater though because that may be too late to get a star 20. If going in a bit this year then it will make sense to get some 19's now though. At this point I am good with going for either option. If Darcy comes back then maybe keep Legare and swing a deal with Hfx for Fucale and Murphy? For this trade to happen they would have to kiss good bye Dubois, O'Leary a 1st rounder and maybe even Bell. Not to mention that Fucale for CB doesn't make a whole lot of sense since there's a good chance he wont be back next season.
|
|
|
Post by hal on Sept 16, 2014 14:44:29 GMT -4
For this trade to happen they would have to kiss good bye Dubois, O'Leary a 1st rounder and maybe even Bell. Not to mention that Fucale for CB doesn't make a whole lot of sense since there's a good chance he wont be back next season. I would say zero chance that Fucale would be back ,he is signed already I believe . I am not giving Dubois and a 1st rounder for Murphy ......at the very least not yet . I want to see how Duchesnes and MacIntyre work out .
|
|
|
Post by Y Ddraig Goch on Sept 16, 2014 14:52:13 GMT -4
Not to mention that Fucale for CB doesn't make a whole lot of sense since there's a good chance he wont be back next season. I would say zero chance that Fucale would be back ,he is signed already I believe . I am not giving Dubois and a 1st rounder for Murphy ......at the very least not yet . I want to see how Duchesnes and MacIntyre work out . You would have to trade for Duchesnes first though.
|
|
|
Post by looneytunes on Sept 16, 2014 15:23:37 GMT -4
For this trade to happen they would have to kiss good bye Dubois, O'Leary a 1st rounder and maybe even Bell. Not to mention that Fucale for CB doesn't make a whole lot of sense since there's a good chance he wont be back next season. True. A trade on that level would absolutely have to be a guaranteed go for it year and not a half in year. Just having some fun. I meant for that trade to happen if Darcy comes back as well. All hypothetical. Fucale would make sense in being able to keep 3 OA's as forwards while getting an elite goaltender. The more I think about any trade with Hfx the more I realize that I big trade to another team in the division would not be fun at all. If an all go for it trade occurs I would rather it be to a Quebec team.
|
|
|
Post by looneytunes on Sept 16, 2014 15:25:49 GMT -4
Not to mention that Fucale for CB doesn't make a whole lot of sense since there's a good chance he wont be back next season. I would say zero chance that Fucale would be back ,he is signed already I believe . I am not giving Dubois and a 1st rounder for Murphy ......at the very least not yet . I want to see how Duchesnes and MacIntyre work out . The wait and see approach would be good. Still a long way off until Christmas but it does look like Dubois will be an elite player in this league.
|
|
|
Post by Y Ddraig Goch on Sept 16, 2014 15:26:07 GMT -4
Not to mention that Fucale for CB doesn't make a whole lot of sense since there's a good chance he wont be back next season. True. A trade on that level would absolutely have to be a guaranteed go for it year and not a half in year. Just having some fun. I meant for that trade to happen if Darcy comes back as well. All hypothetical. Fucale would make sense in being able to keep 3 OA's as forwards while getting an elite goaltender. The more I think about any trade with Hfx the more I realize that I big trade to another team in the division would not be fun at all. If an all go for it trade occurs I would rather it be to a Quebec team. Then Baie-Comeau is probably the best partner. Especially since a good chance you ge Cadorette as an OA too next year.
|
|
|
Post by Y Ddraig Goch on Sept 16, 2014 15:27:06 GMT -4
I would say zero chance that Fucale would be back ,he is signed already I believe . I am not giving Dubois and a 1st rounder for Murphy ......at the very least not yet . I want to see how Duchesnes and MacIntyre work out . The wait and see approach would be good. Still a long way off until Christmas but it does look like Dubois will be an elite player in this league. If you're going to make any big moves then Dubois will be gone as he will be the first thing teams ask for.
|
|
|
Post by looneytunes on Sept 16, 2014 15:43:55 GMT -4
That is true. This board is going to be very lively at Christmas time.
I was a little disappointed at the time of the draft that they did not get Balmas. From what I have seen of Dubois he seems more prepared and to have a higher ceiling. Not disappointed after seeing him play.
|
|
|
Post by Jack Bauer on Sept 16, 2014 15:49:00 GMT -4
If you guys are worried about not having good 20's for next year I will like to add that 20's will not cost as much as a 19 this year. The cost of a decent twenty is usually one early to mid round draft pick. However , the risk is greater though because that may be too late to get a star 20. If going in a bit this year then it will make sense to get some 19's now though. At this point I am good with going for either option. If Darcy comes back then maybe keep Legare and swing a deal with Hfx for Fucale and Murphy? For this trade to happen they would have to kiss good bye Dubois, O'Leary a 1st rounder and maybe even Bell. I hope Halifax wants that kind of value for them as I doubt anyone pays it and we can get 3 impact assets for giving up the 4 you expect for 2 players. Good luck getting any teams top 4 trade chips for those 2. I can see 4 assets going in return, but not that equivalent.
|
|
|
Post by Jack Bauer on Sept 16, 2014 16:28:57 GMT -4
The wait and see approach would be good. Still a long way off until Christmas but it does look like Dubois will be an elite player in this league. If you're going to make any big moves then Dubois will be gone as he will be the first thing teams ask for. I don't buy that at all. Teams declare players off limits all the time. If you're not going to discuss the dozen or so top assets we have because 1 was deemed untouchable then you're only hurting your own team.
|
|