|
Post by hal on Jul 20, 2015 9:54:20 GMT -4
Belanger sure did win his case in the playoffs last year,GAA: 3.91,Save % 896. Sullivan GAA: 2.96,save % 921? Not even close. You people are still on this? Sullivan started 1 game. Stop trying to compare the 2 as if it was a 50/50 split. You People ? .....kinda harsh isn't it ?
|
|
|
Post by Jack Bauer on Jul 20, 2015 10:05:38 GMT -4
You people are still on this? Sullivan started 1 game. Stop trying to compare the 2 as if it was a 50/50 split. You People ? .....kinda harsh isn't it ? No. Clearly there's a 'pro Sullivan' few here and has been ever since we acquired him. They only post pro-Sullivan or anti every other goalie then ignore any bad goal or game he had.
|
|
|
Post by EagleFan2009 on Jul 20, 2015 15:30:22 GMT -4
You People ? .....kinda harsh isn't it ? No. Clearly there's a 'pro Sullivan' few here and has been ever since we acquired him. They only post pro-Sullivan or anti every other goalie then ignore any bad goal or game he had. He's right hal. Every game thread has the posts he's referring to. It's almost as funny as reading the poster on tsn comments named "phaneuf for norris" or whatever
|
|
|
Post by Jack Bauer on Jul 20, 2015 15:41:34 GMT -4
No. Clearly there's a 'pro Sullivan' few here and has been ever since we acquired him. They only post pro-Sullivan or anti every other goalie then ignore any bad goal or game he had. He's right hal. Every game thread has the posts he's referring to. It's almost as funny as reading the poster on tsn comments named "phaneuf for norris" or whatever Yes and the term 'You People' is meant to define a random group. Not to define race or gender in a discriminatory way which is why most people catch heat for using that term. If you and I were pro selling while the majority thought we were crazy I see no issue with someone saying 'you people wanting to sell are crazy'. I don't see how it's at all harsh given the context it was used in. Not like I stopped 2 random immigrants and said 'You people have to go'
|
|
|
Post by yurireeka on Jul 20, 2015 17:01:54 GMT -4
Some people are truly dreamers
|
|
|
Post by hal on Jul 20, 2015 20:16:11 GMT -4
He's right hal. Every game thread has the posts he's referring to. It's almost as funny as reading the poster on tsn comments named "phaneuf for norris" or whatever Yes and the term 'You People' is meant to define a random group. Not to define race or gender in a discriminatory way which is why most people catch heat for using that term. If you and I were pro selling while the majority thought we were crazy I see no issue with someone saying 'you people wanting to sell are crazy'. I don't see how it's at all harsh given the context it was used in. Not like I stopped 2 random immigrants and said 'You people have to go' .....your a rabid Anti-Sullivanite !
|
|
|
Post by BigTwig on Jul 20, 2015 22:15:52 GMT -4
Everybody calm down, all Eaglefan62 and myself are saying is that if either one of us were to be the GM/head coach we would have Sullivan in net over Belanger. Everybody has their own opinions and that is ours and you have yours.
|
|
|
Post by hal on Jul 21, 2015 2:29:57 GMT -4
Everybody calm down, all Eaglefan62 and myself are saying is that if either one of us were to be the GM/head coach we would have Sullivan in net over Belanger. Everybody has their own opinions and that is ours and you have yours. .......which is exactly what "one" of the main purposes of this Board is ....
|
|
|
Post by Jack Bauer on Jul 21, 2015 9:37:52 GMT -4
Everybody calm down, all Eaglefan62 and myself are saying is that if either one of us were to be the GM/head coach we would have Sullivan in net over Belanger. Everybody has their own opinions and that is ours and you have yours. .......which is exactly what "one" of the main purposes of this Board is .... I agree. And at some point we have to move on from our backup goaltender and look at what we have returning. Even if a majority wants Sullivan the fact is he's not going to be here this year. To bring up 1 players stats over 4 periods from last seasons train wreck as any sort of 'fair' evaluation is simply silly.
|
|
|
Post by Jack Bauer on Jul 21, 2015 9:45:34 GMT -4
Yes and the term 'You People' is meant to define a random group. Not to define race or gender in a discriminatory way which is why most people catch heat for using that term. If you and I were pro selling while the majority thought we were crazy I see no issue with someone saying 'you people wanting to sell are crazy'. I don't see how it's at all harsh given the context it was used in. Not like I stopped 2 random immigrants and said 'You people have to go' .....your a rabid Anti-Sullivanite ! I'm not at all anti Sullivan. I am anti over-rating of a goaltender with less then 60 career starts entering an overage season that will not be spent in the CHL. Some here, including yourself, are "pro Cape Breton" to a fault.
|
|
|
Post by hal on Jul 21, 2015 10:37:47 GMT -4
.....your a rabid Anti-Sullivanite ! I'm not at all anti Sullivan. I am anti over-rating of a goaltender with less then 60 career starts entering an overage season that will not be spent in the CHL. Some here, including yourself, are "pro Cape Breton" to a fault. Pro Cape Breton.....to a degree absolutely ....happy to be wrong also .....and for the record I do not think Sullivan is a # 1 nor a 20 .....however do not take that as a ringing endorsement for Belanger as I truly believe the Jury is still out on him but yes he is the best option right now .
|
|
|
Post by bois on Jul 21, 2015 10:41:52 GMT -4
I'm not at all anti Sullivan. I am anti over-rating of a goaltender with less then 60 career starts entering an overage season that will not be spent in the CHL. Some here, including yourself, are "pro Cape Breton" to a fault. Pro Cape Breton.....to a degree absolutely ....happy to be wrong also .....and for the record I do not think Sullivan is a # 1 nor a 20 .....however do not take that as a ringing endorsement for Belanger as I truly believe the Jury is still out on him but yes he is the best option right now . you guys can debate all you want about whether he is a number one or not but there is no question he is a 20 lol
|
|
|
Post by Jack Bauer on Jul 21, 2015 10:41:51 GMT -4
I'm not at all anti Sullivan. I am anti over-rating of a goaltender with less then 60 career starts entering an overage season that will not be spent in the CHL. Some here, including yourself, are "pro Cape Breton" to a fault. Pro Cape Breton.....to a degree absolutely ....happy to be wrong also .....and for the record I do not think Sullivan is a # 1 nor a 20 .....however do not take that as a ringing endorsement for Belanger as I truly believe the Jury is still out on him but yes he is the best option right now . I'm with you 100% on that in both cases. Belanger is the best option of the 2 and even he has a lot to prove. He has 3-4 months to earn himself a shot at being the goaltender on a contending team come playoff time.
|
|
|
Post by Jack Bauer on Jul 21, 2015 10:42:30 GMT -4
Pro Cape Breton.....to a degree absolutely ....happy to be wrong also .....and for the record I do not think Sullivan is a # 1 nor a 20 .....however do not take that as a ringing endorsement for Belanger as I truly believe the Jury is still out on him but yes he is the best option right now . you guys can debate all you want about whether he is a number one or not but there is no question he is a 20 lol
|
|
|
Post by Y Ddraig Goch on Jul 21, 2015 11:09:24 GMT -4
I'm not convinced on Belanger being an OA on a chmapionship team. Is he good enough to take up an OA position? That's what I don't think so.
But.......... are there any 18/19 yo that could be brought in to free up an OA spot.
Perhaps the biggest need is a top-6 centre, not just a forward but centre and another top-4 D. and if they could free up another OA spot there could be a help.
with talk of Halifax being interested in Bowers a deal involving Moynihan/Donaghey could be good for CB but the key to that is CB landing an underage goalie that can carry them.
Maybe Bilia?
|
|