|
|
Post by seadogsofficial on Dec 16, 2019 13:58:18 GMT -4
Hey Guys, First I'll preface this with an apology, as I don't have have any juicy trade rumors to share with everyone  I was hoping to get your help with a project we'll be launching over the break. In celebration of our 15th season we'll be asking our fans to vote for the 15th Anniversary Team. We've been tinkering with some criteria of who should be included, positions etc. and here's what I'm working with right now: 9 forwards, 6 D and 2 goalies Must have played 34 games with the Sea Dogs Doesn't include anyone from this season (unless they played 34+ games last year) You can view the ballot here > forms.gle/QkpFarpW4z4gcuRE8 feel free to test it out. Just looking for feedback on if this criteria makes sense, should we just have every player ever on the list, have all forwards eligible for each position, include this year, and so on. If there are also any glaring omissions please let us know! Thanks! - Jon Q. |
|
|
|
Post by Briwhel on Dec 16, 2019 14:09:24 GMT -4
I would alter the criteria slightly to make playoff MVP Charlie Coyle eligible. Maybe change it from 34 regular season games to 34 overall.
|
|
|
|
Post by radarc on Dec 16, 2019 14:32:08 GMT -4
Looked good - easy to choose the players. Nice if the player you choose was faded as you pick the 2nd/3rd lines for no duplication so you remember who you chose.
|
|
|
|
Post by Judas In My Mind on Dec 16, 2019 14:33:26 GMT -4
I would alter the criteria slightly to make playoff MVP Charlie Coyle eligible. Maybe change it from 34 regular season games to 34 overall. He asked for help picking a team...not help making rules to include your boy crush.  |
|
|
|
Post by j3e4 on Dec 16, 2019 14:54:13 GMT -4
I would alter the criteria slightly to make playoff MVP Charlie Coyle eligible. Maybe change it from 34 regular season games to 34 overall. He asked for help picking a team...not help making rules to include your boy crush. "Just looking for feedback on if this criteria makes sense, should we just have every player ever on the list, have all forwards eligible for each position, include this year, and so on. If there are also any glaring omissions please let us know!" Sounds to me like they are indeed asking for help with the criteria. He also mentioned earlier that they are still tinkering with it. |
|
|
|
Post by Judas In My Mind on Dec 16, 2019 15:06:04 GMT -4
He asked for help picking a team...not help making rules to include your boy crush. "Just looking for feedback on if this criteria makes sense, should we just have every player ever on the list, have all forwards eligible for each position, include this year, and so on. If there are also any glaring omissions please let us know!" Sounds to me like they are indeed asking for help with the criteria. He also mentioned earlier that they are still tinkering with it. Sorry j3e4 that my post about the boy crush of your boy crush offended your delicate sensibilities.  |
|
|
|
Post by lennytheweedwhacker on Dec 16, 2019 15:11:40 GMT -4
Great idea, can't wait to vote - but why not include a full roster. 12 forwards, 6 Defense, and 2 goalies - then challenge the Wildcats anniversary team to a grudge match.
Good work guys.
|
|
|
|
Post by j3e4 on Dec 16, 2019 15:23:16 GMT -4
"Just looking for feedback on if this criteria makes sense, should we just have every player ever on the list, have all forwards eligible for each position, include this year, and so on. If there are also any glaring omissions please let us know!" Sounds to me like they are indeed asking for help with the criteria. He also mentioned earlier that they are still tinkering with it. Sorry j3e4 that my post about the boy crush of your boy crush offended your delicate sensibilities. Happy to help. |
|
|
|
Post by Judas In My Mind on Dec 16, 2019 15:41:25 GMT -4
Hey Guys, First I'll preface this with an apology, as I don't have have any juicy trade rumors to share with everyone I was hoping to get your help with a project we'll be launching over the break. In celebration of our 15th season we'll be asking our fans to vote for the 15th Anniversary Team. We've been tinkering with some criteria of who should be included, positions etc. and here's what I'm working with right now: 9 forwards, 6 D and 2 goalies Must have played 34 games with the Sea Dogs Doesn't include anyone from this season (unless they played 34+ games last year) You can view the ballot here > forms.gle/QkpFarpW4z4gcuRE8 feel free to test it out. Just looking for feedback on if this criteria makes sense, should we just have every player ever on the list, have all forwards eligible for each position, include this year, and so on. If there are also any glaring omissions please let us know! Thanks! - Jon Q. Now on a serious note, yes I do like the format. Its quick and easy to use. If anything I'd prefer the amount of games be raised somewhat, or to "at least one full season". We've been around 15 years now after all. I don't think someone who played half a season, regardless of how good they were in that half season, should make an "All Time Team". Just my opinion though. I honestly don't care if Charlie Coyle, for example, is included or not. |
|
|
|
Post by yoyomamajoe on Dec 16, 2019 17:55:53 GMT -4
There are plenty of players to pick from for a full team of 12F, 6D and 2G
|
|
|
|
Post by iraca on Dec 17, 2019 9:03:41 GMT -4
I like the idea of a full roster AND they must have played a full season (68 games). Rental players shouldn't be on an all time list IMO.
|
|
|
|
Post by Judas In My Mind on Dec 17, 2019 13:18:39 GMT -4
I like the idea of a full roster AND they must have played a full season (68 games). Rental players shouldn't be on an all time list IMO. Thats how I felt too but then I realized it would eliminate guys like Mike Hoffman who did play a full season here but didn't reach the complete 68 regular season games. I think a guy like Hoffman should count. (56 reg. season games) A guy like Coyle should not. (23 reg. season games) But I dont care either way, and a cut-off has to be set somewhere I suppose. |
|
|
|
Post by L'il Boy on Dec 19, 2019 10:28:15 GMT -4
I like the idea of a full roster AND they must have played a full season (68 games). Rental players shouldn't be on an all time list IMO. Thats how I felt too but then I realized it would eliminate guys like Mike Hoffman who did play a full season here but didn't reach the complete 68 regular season games. I think a guy like Hoffman should count. (56 reg. season games) A guy like Coyle should not. (23 reg. season games) But I dont care either way, and a cut-off has to be set somewhere I suppose. IMO, amount of games shouldn't matter. Impact on the team should hold more importance. For instance, without Booth, Gauthier, and\or Bourque, do you guys win the Presidents Cup in 2017? Do you win without Deserres in 2011? There's been so many good\great players that have gone through Saint John, either for a career, or for a short time? Just my thoughts......  |
|
|
|
Post by yoyomamajoe on Jan 15, 2020 10:44:32 GMT -4
|
|
