|
Post by canbeer on Apr 27, 2024 8:51:36 GMT -4
A few things. First I did just say throwing shit at the wall. Also I said the bones of a trade would involve these players. Next I will admit I mixed up your euro goalie with PEI’s euro goalie. Milota had a good year and played well. But why hasn’t he played a game in the playoffs? I know he’s not there now but that’s just this round. To me it does seem like Ruccia is the guy. It doesn’t change the names from Halifax. Sprynar and Cataford help your offence greatly. Not to mention Cataford and Squires would be a dominant line together. They’d be fun to watch all year. Which brings me back to the only way I see you guys getting him is that 1st overall player. Look at Russel’s track record when it comes to these trades. This is a bargain if you only have to pay him now. If it’s in season it will be this player plus Lavoie next draft. There are a lot of factors that will come into play with the value of this 1st overall. If Lawrence will choose the Q and he will play in either Halifax, SJ, or maybe for Quebec, that ups the value significantly. If he would only play for SJ well they'll get him with their 5th anyway. Is there a chance Cibulka plans to play in the Q at 20? If so, would an option to make a major deal with Shawinigan including Tourigny, and trade Schmitt? Shawinigan has the 6th overall and possibly may be eyeing a player above the three Quebec based picks at 2nd, 3rd and 4th. Anyway, loads of scenarios. Regardless, I doubt very much at mid season, pre season or any season would the Eagles trade the 1st overall plus Lavoie at the draft for Cataford and Spryner Not what he said.
|
|
|
Post by gocapebreton on Apr 27, 2024 9:24:00 GMT -4
There are a lot of factors that will come into play with the value of this 1st overall. If Lawrence will choose the Q and he will play in either Halifax, SJ, or maybe for Quebec, that ups the value significantly. If he would only play for SJ well they'll get him with their 5th anyway. Is there a chance Cibulka plans to play in the Q at 20? If so, would an option to make a major deal with Shawinigan including Tourigny, and trade Schmitt? Shawinigan has the 6th overall and possibly may be eyeing a player above the three Quebec based picks at 2nd, 3rd and 4th. Anyway, loads of scenarios. Regardless, I doubt very much at mid season, pre season or any season would the Eagles trade the 1st overall plus Lavoie at the draft for Cataford and Spryner Not what he said. That's what the last line would indicate. Anyway, I doubt they would do that deal anyway.
|
|
|
Post by Briwhel on Apr 27, 2024 9:43:46 GMT -4
And people wonder why out of towners mock trade ideas. Milota's value is much higher than this trade offer reflects. Cataford at Xmas gets you a late 1st, a 2nd, and something for the following season as a future. Cataford and a late pick getting you a 1st overall isn't happening. A few things. First I did just say throwing shit at the wall. Also I said the bones of a trade would involve these players. Next I will admit I mixed up your euro goalie with PEI’s euro goalie. Milota had a good year and played well. But why hasn’t he played a game in the playoffs? I know he’s not there now but that’s just this round. To me it does seem like Ruccia is the guy. It doesn’t change the names from Halifax. Sprynar and Cataford help your offence greatly. Not to mention Cataford and Squires would be a dominant line together. They’d be fun to watch all year. Which brings me back to the only way I see you guys getting him is that 1st overall player. Look at Russel’s track record when it comes to these trades. This is a bargain if you only have to pay him now. If it’s in season it will be this player plus Lavoie next draft. Springer doesn't help anyone's offense greatly. He scored a whopping 38 points this year including 28 games on a contender.
|
|
|
Post by randohockeyguy on Apr 27, 2024 11:03:56 GMT -4
that won’t happen as he’s already been traded and it ain’t CAPE Breton that’s for sure. Just FYI🤫 So there’s only one trade that is already made and he’s no part of that. As for any other trade that could be just a hand shake agreement things can change. Key example look at Desnoyers to SJ. That as you recall was a done deal. Catafords is a 98% done from what I heard from my people the…. Denoyers trade was not as close as people thought. I don’t know why Jeff Merck would go and say that on live tv when he barely ever talks about junior hockey as is and usually only posts done trades with support from the league … keep in mind he also did not get his contract renewed … take that with a grain of salt.
|
|
|
Post by Briwhel on Apr 27, 2024 11:54:25 GMT -4
So there’s only one trade that is already made and he’s no part of that. As for any other trade that could be just a hand shake agreement things can change. Key example look at Desnoyers to SJ. That as you recall was a done deal. Catafords is a 98% done from what I heard from my people the…. Denoyers trade was not as close as people thought. I don’t know why Jeff Merck would go and say that on live tv when he barely ever talks about junior hockey as is and usually only posts done trades with support from the league … keep in mind he also did not get his contract renewed … take that with a grain of salt. You are wrong about the Desnoyers trade. It was done to the point where all the players were informed.
|
|
|
Post by Smiley on Apr 27, 2024 11:56:18 GMT -4
A few things. First I did just say throwing shit at the wall. Also I said the bones of a trade would involve these players. Next I will admit I mixed up your euro goalie with PEI’s euro goalie. Milota had a good year and played well. But why hasn’t he played a game in the playoffs? I know he’s not there now but that’s just this round. To me it does seem like Ruccia is the guy. It doesn’t change the names from Halifax. Sprynar and Cataford help your offence greatly. Not to mention Cataford and Squires would be a dominant line together. They’d be fun to watch all year. Which brings me back to the only way I see you guys getting him is that 1st overall player. Look at Russel’s track record when it comes to these trades. This is a bargain if you only have to pay him now. If it’s in season it will be this player plus Lavoie next draft. Springer doesn't help anyone's offense greatly. He scored a whopping 38 points this year including 28 games on a contender. Some are just selling every player, but the Moose will still keep players (Schultz, Sprynar, Martin). The top 4 are most likely moved (Cataford, Rooster, Vid and Mackinnon). But they (the Moose) won’t dress a Junior A team. Players like Sprynar are probably more beneficial to the Moose than they get back in a trade. The younger players still need support for growth and the Moose will draft a new Euro this year, and then they have staggered Euro’s (picking another next year with a better pick). Now come Christmas one of those players could be moved if they just dominate and get a great return but right now the value is higher to Halifax than they get in a trade.
|
|
|
Post by statsman18 on Apr 27, 2024 12:58:55 GMT -4
So there’s only one trade that is already made and he’s no part of that. As for any other trade that could be just a hand shake agreement things can change. Key example look at Desnoyers to SJ. That as you recall was a done deal. Catafords is a 98% done from what I heard from my people the…. Denoyers trade was not as close as people thought. I don’t know why Jeff Merck would go and say that on live tv when he barely ever talks about junior hockey as is and usually only posts done trades with support from the league … keep in mind he also did not get his contract renewed … take that with a grain of salt. What are you talking about his contract wasn’t renewed? He’s still very much with SN. Please enlighten all of us to said trade that is 98% done?
|
|
|
Post by statsman18 on Apr 27, 2024 13:17:54 GMT -4
A few things. First I did just say throwing shit at the wall. Also I said the bones of a trade would involve these players. Next I will admit I mixed up your euro goalie with PEI’s euro goalie. Milota had a good year and played well. But why hasn’t he played a game in the playoffs? I know he’s not there now but that’s just this round. To me it does seem like Ruccia is the guy. It doesn’t change the names from Halifax. Sprynar and Cataford help your offence greatly. Not to mention Cataford and Squires would be a dominant line together. They’d be fun to watch all year. Which brings me back to the only way I see you guys getting him is that 1st overall player. Look at Russel’s track record when it comes to these trades. This is a bargain if you only have to pay him now. If it’s in season it will be this player plus Lavoie next draft. Springer doesn't help anyone's offense greatly. He scored a whopping 38 points this year including 28 games on a contender. That’s right he doesn’t ware a blue uniform so someone will be better. As a Moosehead his numbers went up drastically. As a Moosehead he went from 0.10 goals a game to 0.55, which translates to a 35 goal season. Now we all know you’re going to say Matekio is better but he only had a 0.44 goals per game, which doesn’t even add up to a 30 goal season.
|
|
|
Post by canbeer on Apr 27, 2024 14:22:38 GMT -4
So what teams would we be guessing are the bottom 5 next year.
Quebec I’d assume barring big futures. Didn’t have much left at the end and I think their two top scorers were 20s. Maybe the safest bet for bottom 5?
Val D’or can probably return most of their top dozen guys and had some rookies in that mix… should move up in standings.
Ryn and Drumm may fall a furthest out of the top 4 teams. Drum especially with Gauthier traded loose a ton up front. Ryn minus Rousseau had poor goaltending and their D core could lose 5 of their top 6. Not sure how far they both fall but it will be interesting to see if they lose some futures as well.
Anyways just wondering what the opinions are for which teams find themselves at the bottom next year.
|
|
|
Post by sherwood1020 on Apr 27, 2024 14:45:51 GMT -4
So what teams would we be guessing are the bottom 5 next year. Quebec I’d assume barring big futures. Didn’t have much left at the end and I think their two top scorers were 20s. Maybe the safest bet for bottom 5? Val D’or can probably return most of their top dozen guys and had some rookies in that mix… should move up in standings. Ryn and Drumm may fall a furthest out of the top 4 teams. Drum especially with Gauthier traded loose a ton up front. Ryn minus Rousseau had poor goaltending and their D core could lose 5 of their top 6. Not sure how far they both fall but it will be interesting to see if they lose some futures as well. Anyways just wondering what the opinions are for which teams find themselves at the bottom next year. Bottom 5 next season will probably be similar to this season SJ Val-d'Or Quebec Charlottetown Random Quebec team
|
|
|
Post by Briwhel on Apr 27, 2024 15:05:17 GMT -4
Springer doesn't help anyone's offense greatly. He scored a whopping 38 points this year including 28 games on a contender. That’s right he doesn’t ware a blue uniform so someone will be better. As a Moosehead his numbers went up drastically. As a Moosehead he went from 0.10 goals a game to 0.55, which translates to a 35 goal season. Now we all know you’re going to say Matekio is better but he only had a 0.44 goals per game, which doesn’t even add up to a 30 goal season. Yes, let's completely ignore silly things like linemate calibre and that he played 28 games on a team that was supposed to be a top 4 team and he still wasn't PPG. He's not only not the top 05 import in the league (what you are idiotically suggesting), he's objectively worse than Simek (SJ's 2nd best import).
|
|
|
Post by statsman18 on Apr 27, 2024 17:37:46 GMT -4
That’s right he doesn’t ware a blue uniform so someone will be better. As a Moosehead his numbers went up drastically. As a Moosehead he went from 0.10 goals a game to 0.55, which translates to a 35 goal season. Now we all know you’re going to say Matekio is better but he only had a 0.44 goals per game, which doesn’t even add up to a 30 goal season. Yes, let's completely ignore silly things like linemate calibre and that he played 28 games on a team that was supposed to be a top 4 team and he still wasn't PPG. He's not only not the top 05 import in the league (what you are idiotically suggesting), he's objectively worse than Simek (SJ's 2nd best import). One never said he was the best. Please show me where I said that. Also all I’m saying is he is better than the Euro forward they have. I’ll save you the trouble, they don’t have one so it’s not hard. Next you want to talk about line mates he played with the 3rd line other than special teams with Halifax. Go watch the highlights of the game on March 2 where he had 3 points, first star against your beloved Dogs. Then go watch the game on the 8th of March to see him get 2 points and another 1st star against the same beloved Sea Dogs. None of his points are with anyone who would be top line guys. Lastly don’t end an argument with the word “Objectively” like it’s a mic drop. Especially when you want to say the player who is “Objectively” better than was held point in both games I used as examples.
|
|
|
Post by randohockeyguy on Apr 27, 2024 18:20:50 GMT -4
Catafords is a 98% done from what I heard from my people the…. Denoyers trade was not as close as people thought. I don’t know why Jeff Merck would go and say that on live tv when he barely ever talks about junior hockey as is and usually only posts done trades with support from the league … keep in mind he also did not get his contract renewed … take that with a grain of salt. What are you talking about his contract wasn’t renewed? He’s still very much with SN. Please enlighten all of us to said trade that is 98% done? i mean he only kept his own podcast he’s not on HNIC or 32 thoughts …. And I can’t disclose the trade as that goes against team morales
|
|
|
Post by statsman18 on Apr 27, 2024 18:41:14 GMT -4
What are you talking about his contract wasn’t renewed? He’s still very much with SN. Please enlighten all of us to said trade that is 98% done? i mean he only kept his own podcast he’s not on HNIC or 32 thoughts …. And I can’t disclose the trade as that goes against team morales Are you part of the team?
|
|
|
Post by howitzer on Apr 27, 2024 19:31:58 GMT -4
What are you talking about his contract wasn’t renewed? He’s still very much with SN. Please enlighten all of us to said trade that is 98% done? i mean he only kept his own podcast he’s not on HNIC or 32 thoughts …. And I can’t disclose the trade as that goes against team morales Marek isn't on HNIC, but he most certainly is still apart of 32 Thoughts. It's him and Elliotte.
|
|