|
|
Post by wildcatsss on May 15, 2024 14:18:03 GMT -4
That, we already know! Irving said during the press conference this morning that he will "put on a show at draft day" so in addition to the Vidicek/MacKinnon trade we should expect another trade to get a first round draft pick. I'll let you guess the player that will be "sacrificed" for either of those trades... I guess I could see Collard or maybe Smith moved? not sure who else could potentially net us a first unless it involves moving up with other picks Smith absolutety 250% doesn't worth a first rounder |
|
|
|
Post by Marshall on May 15, 2024 14:25:07 GMT -4
Hearing rumours that shawinigan may move a first , and Peitche wants out , maybe smith and Carrier and a mid round pic for a first and Peitzche .
|
|
|
|
Post by wildcatsss on May 15, 2024 15:06:29 GMT -4
Hearing rumours that shawinigan may move a first , and Peitche wants out , maybe smith and Carrier and a mid round pic for a first and Peitzche . MacDougall would be insane to do that trade and Shawinigan would laugh their asses off...They paid 2 first rounder to draft Carrier, so they'll probably ask the same in return or something similar. Smith worth at least a low 2nd or high 3rd rounder. Adding to that, the value of Peitzche is really not that high |
|
|
|
Post by davo1997 on May 15, 2024 15:10:43 GMT -4
Hearing rumours that shawinigan may move a first , and Peitche wants out , maybe smith and Carrier and a mid round pic for a first and Peitzche . I cant see Collard being moved he had a really goos season this year i can see him putting up 75pts in his 19 year old season. Shawinigan bid on the Mem Cup so they will probably be buyers |
|
|
|
Post by Briwhel on May 15, 2024 15:14:43 GMT -4
Vidicek and Mackinnon incoming That, we already know! Irving said during the press conference this morning that he will "put on a show at draft day" so in addition to the Vidicek/MacKinnon trade we should expect another trade to get a first round draft pick. I'll let you guess the player that will be "sacrificed" for either of those trades... I'd be shocked if Moncton does that. They should be heading in the other direction and adding more pieces. |
|
|
|
Post by xkarlsson65x on May 15, 2024 15:15:51 GMT -4
Hearing rumours that shawinigan may move a first , and Peitche wants out , maybe smith and Carrier and a mid round pic for a first and Peitzche . I cant see Collard being moved he had a really goos season this year i can see him putting up 75pts in his 19 year old season. Shawinigan bid on the Mem Cup so they will probably be buyers Based on where we are in the cycle i dont think we should be trading away a good goal scorer but his end of the season (last 15-20 games of the regular season and playoffs) he really wasnt as noticeable as the start of the year. His skating and absolute bone-headed cross checks to the face are the only reason i could see him being "sacrificed" in this hypothetical scenario. |
|
|
|
Post by davo1997 on May 15, 2024 15:17:31 GMT -4
I cant see Collard being moved he had a really goos season this year i can see him putting up 75pts in his 19 year old season. Shawinigan bid on the Mem Cup so they will probably be buyers Based on where we are in the cycle i dont think we should be trading away a good goal scorer but his end of the season (last 15-20 games of the regular season and playoffs) he really wasnt as noticeable as the start of the year. His skating and absolute bone-headed cross checks to the face are the only reason i could see him being "sacrificed" in this hypothetical scenario. would make sense for Shawinigan to be in on Collard i guess but if im moncton id wait until the deadline to move on from him. hes the type of guy to make you regret it if he plays you in the playoffs. |
|
|
|
Post by Marshall on May 15, 2024 15:28:02 GMT -4
Hearing rumours that shawinigan may move a first , and Peitche wants out , maybe smith and Carrier and a mid round pic for a first and Peitzche . MacDougall would be insane to do that trade and Shawinigan would laugh their asses off...They paid 2 first rounder to draft Carrier, so they'll probably ask the same in return or something similar. Smith worth at least a low 2nd or high 3rd rounder. Adding to that, the value of Peitzche is really not that high Peitzche is a second rounder , he played great in shawi just needed the opportunity to play , Halifax didn’t give him that , I think just the opposite of you I don’t think smiths trade capital is high , more of a third 4th line grinder but he is tough that’s his big asset . Moncton got hosed paying 2 firsts for carrier in a very weak draft year . In the 06 draft year he may be a mid to late 3rd rounder . Anyways just a thought for discussion purposes I respect everyone’s opinion . Congrats as well on landing Gardner he’s a great person and coach . |
|
|
|
Post by davo1997 on May 15, 2024 15:31:12 GMT -4
MacDougall would be insane to do that trade and Shawinigan would laugh their asses off...They paid 2 first rounder to draft Carrier, so they'll probably ask the same in return or something similar. Smith worth at least a low 2nd or high 3rd rounder. Adding to that, the value of Peitzche is really not that high Peitzche is a second rounder , he played great in shawi just needed the opportunity to play , Halifax didn’t give him that , I think just the opposite of you I don’t think smiths trade capital is high , more of a third 4th line grinder but he is tough that’s his big asset . Moncton got hosed paying 2 firsts for carrier in a very weak draft year . I’m the 06 draft year he may be a mid to late 3rd rounder . Anyways just a thought for discussion purposes I respect everyone’s opinion . Smith would be a good 3rd liner to have physical and the skill is there. Carrier is gonna be good he had no oppurtunity in Moncton this year |
|
|
|
Post by wildcatsss on May 15, 2024 15:41:13 GMT -4
MacDougall would be insane to do that trade and Shawinigan would laugh their asses off...They paid 2 first rounder to draft Carrier, so they'll probably ask the same in return or something similar. Smith worth at least a low 2nd or high 3rd rounder. Adding to that, the value of Peitzche is really not that high Peitzche is a second rounder , he played great in shawi just needed the opportunity to play , Halifax didn’t give him that , I think just the opposite of you I don’t think smiths trade capital is high , more of a third 4th line grinder but he is tough that’s his big asset . Moncton got hosed paying 2 firsts for carrier in a very weak draft year . In the 06 draft year he may be a mid to late 3rd rounder . Anyways just a thought for discussion purposes I respect everyone’s opinion . Congrats as well on landing Gardner he’s a great person and coach . Funniest thing I read all week long! I can see you didn't follow the Cats very much this season. 1) Last years draft top 10 was one of the best of the last few years (talked to many many scouts) 2) 06' draft was pretty weak, not 07' 3) Carrier would have been drafted top 3 in the 06' draft without a single doubt. 3rd round in 06' draft? Sorry but that is total nonsense. He played 6 min a game this year and Lacroix gave him nothing and he still managed to shine everytime he got I respect your opinion, but it is certainly not supported by any facts. |
|
|
|
Post by WildcatMapleLeafs on May 15, 2024 15:43:42 GMT -4
Moving Collard or Smith would be a mistake. I could see a 1st and player incoming for Carrier though
|
|
|
|
Post by wildcatsss on May 15, 2024 15:47:00 GMT -4
Moving Collard or Smith would be a mistake. I could see a 1st and player incoming for Carrier though Also my thought... |
|
|
|
Post by xkarlsson65x on May 15, 2024 15:55:41 GMT -4
I know he could bring in some assets but man, moving Carrier would sting. You can see the skill there at 16.
|
|
kuba
Draft Pick
Posts: 104 
|
Post by kuba on May 15, 2024 16:02:38 GMT -4
Do we see Miles Mueller return for a fourth season after all ?
|
|
|
|
Post by joehockey on May 15, 2024 16:12:18 GMT -4
MacDougall would be insane to do that trade and Shawinigan would laugh their asses off...They paid 2 first rounder to draft Carrier, so they'll probably ask the same in return or something similar. Smith worth at least a low 2nd or high 3rd rounder. Adding to that, the value of Peitzche is really not that high Peitzche is a second rounder , he played great in shawi just needed the opportunity to play , Halifax didn’t give him that , I think just the opposite of you I don’t think smiths trade capital is high , more of a third 4th line grinder but he is tough that’s his big asset . Moncton got hosed paying 2 firsts for carrier in a very weak draft year . In the 06 draft year he may be a mid to late 3rd rounder . Anyways just a thought for discussion purposes I respect everyone’s opinion . Congrats as well on landing Gardner he’s a great person and coach . I’d rather have Smith than Peitzche. They’re the same age, but Smith is bigger and more physical. They had practically the same amount of points with Smith playing 15 less games. I don’t see anyway that Smith’s value is lower than Peitzche’s value. |
|
